Skip to content
Looking for coffee carts & catering? Click here

Coffee guides · Espresso

Why is my espresso sour?

Sour espresso is almost always under-extracted: the water ran through too fast to pull the sweetness out. Grind finer first, and aim for about twice the dose in the cup in 25–30 seconds.

The short answer

Grind finer. If the shot already takes 25–30 seconds and still tastes sour, raise the temperature a degree or let a few more grams into the cup. Change one thing at a time.

What sour means

Coffee gives up its flavours in an order. The bright, sharp acids come out first; the sugars and the heavier, rounder flavours come later. Stop too early and you get the acids without the sweetness to balance them. That is under-extraction, and it tastes sharp, thin and salty-sour, like a lemon squeezed into weak tea. The finish is short and leaves your mouth watering.

Sour is not the same as bitter. Bitter is the other end: harsh, drying, lingering. If you can’t tell which you have, read why espresso tastes bitter too; the fixes run in opposite directions.

Check these in order

  • 1. Grind. The most common cause by far. If the shot runs well under 25 seconds, the grind is too coarse and water rushes through. Go a step or two finer and pull another shot.
  • 2. Dose against the basket. Too little coffee in a large basket leaves room for water to race through. Use the dose your basket is rated for: 20 g in a 51 mm double, 21 g in a 54 mm, 23 g in a 58 mm, as in our espresso guide.
  • 3. Yield and time. Weigh the shot. Aim for about twice the dose in the cup (18 g in, 36 g out) in 25–30 seconds from pump on. A shot stopped well short of that can taste sour even when the time is right.
  • 4. Temperature. We brew at 93 °C. A machine that hasn’t warmed up for 15–20 minutes, or a cold portafilter, pulls cooler and sourer. Warm the machine properly, then try a degree hotter if yours lets you set it.
  • 5. The beans themselves. Very fresh beans give off a lot of gas, which can push water through unevenly and taste sharp; very old beans taste flat and hollow, with nothing behind the acidity. Neither is fixed by the grinder alone. See how long beans stay fresh.
  • 6. The roast. Light roasts are brighter by design and harder to extract. Some of that sharpness is meant to be there. A medium roast like ours is denser than a dark one, so it usually wants a few steps finer than a supermarket dark roast.

Fix table

What you see and tasteLikely causeChange one thing
Sour, thin, shot done well under 25 sGrind too coarseGrind finer, a step or two
Still fast at the grinder’s finest settingToo little coffee for the basketDose to the basket’s rating
Right time, but sharp and syrupy-smallToo little in the cupLet a few more grams through, towards 2× the dose
2× the dose in 25–30 s, still sourWater too coolRaise the temperature 1 °C, or warm the machine longer
Sour and bitter at once, spurting or uneven flowChannelling: uneven bedLevel the grounds and tamp straight; the grind is probably fine
Flat and hollow, little aroma from the bagStale beansA fresh bag; no setting brings aroma back
Sour only with oat or almond milkBright coffee meeting a less forgiving milkSee coffee with plant milk

Move one thing per shot and taste each one. Change the grind and the dose together and you won’t know which fixed it. Our guide to dialling in a new bag sets out the full routine.

Sour, or just bright?

Good espresso has some acidity. It should taste lively, like a ripe fruit, then sweet. Sourness is acidity with nothing behind it. With our blend, a shot that is right tastes of caramel and milk chocolate first, with a soft, creamy finish. If you’re getting sharpness and no caramel, keep grinding finer.

Questions

Why is my espresso sour?

It is under-extracted, usually because the grind is too coarse and the shot runs too fast. Grind finer until you get about twice the dose in the cup in 25–30 seconds.

Should I grind finer or coarser if espresso is sour?

Finer. Sour means the water passed through too quickly. Coarser is the fix for bitter.

Why is my espresso sour and watery?

The shot is running fast. Grind finer, and check you are using the full dose your basket is rated for; too little coffee in a big basket runs thin.

Why is my espresso sour even though the shot takes 30 seconds?

Check the yield: if you are stopping well short of twice the dose, let a few more grams through. If the yield is right, the water may be too cool; warm the machine fully or raise the temperature a degree.

Can espresso be sour and bitter at the same time?

Yes, when water channels through cracks in the coffee bed: part of it over-extracts and part under-extracts. Distribute the grounds evenly and tamp level before changing the grind.

A blend made for espresso

Buy whole beans

The full recipe

Espresso guide