Coffee guides · Compare
Plunger vs AeroPress vs pour-over
Choose a plunger if you want two full-bodied mugs with the least fuss, an AeroPress if you make one clean cup at a time and want it quick, and pour-over if you want the cleanest, lightest cup and don’t mind standing at the kettle for three minutes.
The short answer
All three make good black coffee from the same beans. The differences are body, how many cups you get at once, and how much attention each one asks for. None of them makes espresso.
Side by side
| Plunger | AeroPress | Pour-over | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste and body | Heavy, rich body; some fine sediment in the last mouthful | Clean and rounded; medium body | Cleanest and lightest; the clearest flavours |
| Filter | Metal mesh: lets oils and fine particles through | Paper disc | Paper filter |
| Cups per brew | Two mugs from our 500 ml recipe (bigger plungers make more) | One cup, 220 ml | One large cup, 320 ml |
| Brew time | 4 minutes, plus boiling the kettle | About 2 minutes | About 3 minutes |
| Effort | Least: add, pour, wait, press | Low, a few more steps | Most: a slow, steady pour you have to stand over |
| Clean-up | Wet grounds to scoop out and a mesh to rinse | Easiest: the puck pops into the bin | Easy: lift out the paper and grounds together |
| Grind | Coarse, like raw sugar | Medium-fine, like fine sand | Medium, like coarse sand |
| Gear cost | Low | Low | Low for the cone; a pouring kettle helps and adds to it |
| Coffee per cup, our beans | 15 g a mug: 78 cents to $1.14 | 15 g: 78 cents to $1.14 | 20 g: $1.04 to $1.52 |
| Our ground coffee | Works; a touch finer than ideal, so steep 3½ minutes | Works; a touch coarser than ideal, so steep 2 minutes | Works as it is |
Coffee cost per cup is from our cost-per-cup page: the low end is our over-6 kg-a-month subscription price, the high end a one-off 250 g bag. We haven’t priced the brewers themselves; all three are cheap next to an espresso machine. Grind sizes are explained in our grind size chart.
Our recipes
| Coffee | Water | Temperature | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plunger | 30 g, coarse (four level tablespoons) | 500 ml, ratio 1:16 | About 94 °C (boiled, then 30 s) | Stir at 1 minute, press slowly at 4 |
| AeroPress | 15 g, medium-fine | 220 ml | 85 °C | Steep 1:30, press 30 s |
| Pour-over | 20 g, medium | 320 ml, ratio 1:16 | 94 °C | 30 s bloom, finished by 3 minutes |
Why the ratios differ, and how to scale them, is in our brew ratio guide.
Which should you choose?
- Two of you, or two mugs in the morning: plunger. It makes several cups at once and asks almost nothing of you. Pour it all out when you press, or it keeps brewing and turns bitter.
- One cup at a time, or at work and travelling: AeroPress. It is fast, small, hard to break and the quickest to clean. It makes one cup per press.
- You drink it black and like to taste the beans: pour-over. The paper filter takes out the oils and sediment, so the cup is light and clear. It rewards a steady pour and punishes a rushed one.
- You like a heavy, rich cup, or take milk: plunger. The mesh lets the oils through, which gives the body that stands up to a splash of milk.
- You want flat whites and lattes: none of these. They need espresso and steamed milk; see espresso machine vs plunger.
Questions
Is AeroPress better than a French press?
Neither is better; they make different cups. An AeroPress uses a paper filter, so its coffee is cleaner and lighter, and it makes one cup in about two minutes. A French press (plunger) makes several mugs at once with a heavier, richer body and a little sediment.
Is pour-over better than a French press?
Pour-over gives a cleaner, lighter cup with clearer flavours because the paper filter holds back oils and fine particles. A French press gives more body and is easier. If you drink it black and like to taste the beans, try pour-over; if you want ease or take milk, the plunger.
Which brewing method makes the strongest coffee?
Strength comes from how much coffee you use for the water, not the brewer. Our plunger and pour-over recipes both use a 1:16 ratio, so they are about as strong as each other. Use more coffee in any of them for a stronger cup.
Can I use the same ground coffee for plunger, AeroPress and pour-over?
Yes, with small changes. Our ground coffee is one medium grind: it suits pour-over as it is, works in a plunger with a 3½-minute steep, and in an AeroPress with a 2-minute steep. Whole beans ground for each method are better still.
Which is easiest to clean, AeroPress or plunger?
The AeroPress: you push the used coffee out as a puck straight into the bin and rinse the plunger. A French press leaves wet grounds in the jug and the mesh to rinse.
